• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Debra Pascali-Bonaro

Awaken Your Inner Wisdom

  • ABOUT
    • ABOUT DEBRA
    • INVITE DEBRA TO SPEAK
    • START HERE
    • OUR TEAM
    • PRAISE
    • GIVE BACK
  • DOULA WORKSHOPS
    • DOULA SCHOLARSHIPS
  • DOULA RETREATS
  • EDUCATION FOR PARENTS
  • BLOG
    • BIRTH STORIES
      • Share your Story
  • PODCAST
  • CONTACT

Do Something

Donations of Love, Peace and Caring

523502_664467216916869_1867953166_nWe are One World.  I am filled with gratitude that my dear friends and colleagues are offering their heart, hands and midwifery skills to save and improve lives of MotherBaby’s and families in the Philippines.

As chair of the International MotherBaby Childbirth Organization, two of our MotherBaby Networks are now on the front lines of saving precious lives in the Philippines and welcoming new life in with peace and love. Join me in supporting them. This Thanksgiving if you are having a family dinner, consider providing the cost of one portion to either of our MBNet’s, so they can serve the people of the Philippines. During the holiday season, I am asking instead of gifts that my friends and family donate to one or both of these important, life saving and life enhancing missions.

Robin Lim, Katherine Bramhall, and team Bumi Sehat invite YOU to make a difference for mothers and young children in the Philippines by donating to Bumi Sehat. Robin is now in Cebu in the Philippines to deliver midwifery and medical relief for the most vulnerable of its victims: pregnant women and young children. When pregnant women cease to have food, water and shelter, blood pressure rises, babies are born too soon or are stillborn.  The only way to prevent this is to feed and care for them. Join  A Million Mother’s on Facebook.

Ways you can help Bumi Sehat:
– Share http://www.amillionmothers.org/ link with your friends and associates
– Donate to A Million Mothers
– Send Protein Bars (you ship, pls. check address with Bumi)
– Send Solar Suitcases Water Purifiers (you ship, pls. check address with Bumi)
– Send Gift Donation in honor of a Mother you know to Million Mothers
– Send $1 and ask all the mothers you know to send $1

The suffering in the Philippines has only just begun.

Mercy in Action is our other MBNet in the Philippines. Vicki and Scott Penwell, Ian and Rose Penwell of Mercy in Action write, “In the aftermath, experts are calling for help from Midwives and Doctors to deliver the traumatized pregnant women and care for the babies, (many being born prematurely) and that is what we are specialist in. We also teach disaster preparedness and we know how to conduct deliveries at home, and how to help premature babies with Kangaroo Care who have no incubators. Plus, we are Alaskans, as well as long time missionaries in a third world context…able to do hard things and function without running water and electricity… We were born for such a time as this….We need to go…”

Ways to help Mercy in Action:

– Donate to Mercy in Action

– Send vitamins to help survivors build up their immune systems

– Send medical supplies (especially GLOVES) to:

Mercy Midwives Birthing Home, 1835 Bennet Road, Old Cabalan, Olongapo, 2200 Philippines.

To see more about the Typhoon babies and needs for MotherBaby’s of the Philippines visit  http://edition.cnn.com/2013/11/16/world/asia/phillippines-baby-clinic/

Mercy in Action writes, “So please send a cash donation in any amount you can afford, or an amount you can’t afford but you will do by faith. Or ask your family to help save babies this Christmas instead of extra presents.” www.mercyinaction.com

Thank you for holding these amazing midwives in your heart, thoughts and prayers.

Love Heals,

With gratitude and love,

Debra

One World- Love, Peace and Wisdom by Bliss

Heal the World Lyrics by Michael Jackson

 

Please donate to Mercy in Action Relief Efforts

Please donate to Bumi Sehat Relief Efforts

 

Tweet

Personal Becomes Political thru Birth Stories

Hermine Introducing Panel
Hermine Hayes Klein introducing panel at Human Rights in Childbirth Conference, Belgium 2013.

While in Belgium for Midwifery Today I visited a IMBCO Demo site and attended the Human Rights in Childbirth Conference (HRiC). All the events and conferences reignited my passion and dedication to ensure every MotherBaby has the right to respect, dignity and informed decision making in childbirth as well as every midwife and doula has the right to practice autonomously. The language of birth is changing as we bring a much needed human rights frame-work to quality maternity care, as well as release our current fear and pain language to replace it of one of possibilities, health and pleasure.

Attending HRiC also made me feel a huge sadness- the weight of all the stories and the pain combined with the hope that they were all coming together.  Speaking-out and seeking change in a legal and medical system, one can’t help but wonder if the current system looked in the mirror and saw the pain it is causing, would it really continue in this model?  I hope No, I always believe we have good people, but a broken system- a dysfunctional system.  I have faith that change is coming if we can peel away the veil of silence and build a system of respectful care (see whiteribbonalliance.org/respectfulcare for more on respectful care).

Hermine Hayes Klein of HRiC framed the day, “It is through stories that the personal becomes political.”  Here is a snapshot of some of the stories that came together at the conference:

ANA
My heart ached as doula, Ana Raposeira from Portugal, shared her story. Imagine how it feels to be with a family for a birth where the baby dies 8 hours later, and then to be charged with murder of that baby? Ana’s love and caring provided them with precious skin-to-skin time for a baby with multiple anomalies, that were undetected by ultrasounds and the medical professionals, and were most likely incompatible with life.  Ana’s intuition had her stay longer and then to call the midwife to return, which lead to them seeking more care.  She did all she could and remained within her role as a doula- within her scope of practice and code of ethics.  I have faith she will be proven innocent.  Soon we will be sharing her video statement with a link to donate to her legal defense fund. At that time, I hope you will join me in supporting her with our love, nurturing, and if you can to help, with her legal defense fund, as every dollar makes a difference! Thank you in advance!

DANIELA
In Italy Daniela is taking her physician to court for doing an episiotomy after repeated refusal.  She suffered PTSD, and the Facebook group facebook.com/humanrightsinchildbirth inspired her to take a stand and appeal her case to determine what is “admittable” consent as consent is not often sought in Italy for episiotomy, induction, and amniotomy.

Hermine Hayes-Klein writes in her blog for O Birth Courage & Insanity, from Suffrage to Childbirth: “I think of Daniela in Italy, who sought far and wide during pregnancy for a provider who wouldn’t cut an episiotomy.  She was promised that the hospital where she would deliver would respect her insistence that an episiotomy not be cut. She told every single provider that she spoke with, during pregnancy and then during her labor at the hospital, that under no circumstances did she want an episiotomy.  She told this more than once to the doctor who ended up between her legs while her baby came out.  When the baby was crowning, that doctor reached for scissors and started cutting an episiotomy.  Daniela screamed “No!” from the depths of her soul.  The doctor looked up, hesitated, and then cut a long, deep episiotomy.

“When medical staff visited her bed after the birth, Daniela was deeply upset.  She felt profoundly violated and traumatized.  She spoke up, loudly, about what had happened and stated that her legal and human rights had been violated.  The obstetricians called the psychiatrists, who came to suggest that, in her state, she might pose a danger to her newborn child.  After she left the hospital, Daniela was visited twice at her home by psychiatrists, without an invitation.  On top of the trauma of the episiotomy was added this violation of her safe space, her home, and the need to then convince these psychiatrists that they need not involve child protective services and take away her new baby.”

KRYSIA
Dutch Midwife Krysia Lynch and the homebirth of twins case…. One thing I learned is we tend to make things difficult but it is not that hard, the question should not be “Should a woman under any circumstance have the right to give birth at home?” The question should be “Who will assist her?”  A woman can exercise her right alone.  We should never use coercion or force women to what others see as the civilized choice.  There will always be homebirth, who has the expertise, what area of expertise is essential?  Midwives are the experts here, and the expertise of the birthing women we need to trust.  We can learn.  We need to be held accountable, transparent, open and honest.

AJA
Teehan v Health Service Executive and Minister for Health, Ireland May 2013.  Aja was an expectant mother who exercised her choice to have an assisted birth at home. Aja took steps to have her homebirth by providing the HSE with the following information; a detailed letter with research on VBAC safety; details of her personal circumstances including good health, yoga, and gymnastics; and the OB report indicating she was lowest risk and should be granted home birth. Aja’s request was refused and she took action. Aja writes in her blog, Aja Teehan vs HSE and Minister for Health: “I have brought this case because of the HSE’s refusal to allow me to have a home birth with the assistance of a midwife. HSE policy along with changes in the law mean that it is no longer possible for any expectant mother to have a home birth unless they fit within a rigid criteria; I cannot access one publicly, or privately. When the HSE refused my application for home birth, they did not assess me as an individual mother and imposed a blanket policy. I have right to autonomy and family rights, which are guaranteed by the European Convention of Human Rights and our Constitution. I am seeking to vindicate my rights.”

And from, “To All Those Who Do Not Understand, I Will Defend You.”  Aja writes, “Many aspects of this complex case have been misunderstood; some people even think I want to force everyone to have a home-birth.  This is not about my homebirth, this is about every birth:  I am defending you in your birth; I am defending your mothers, your daughters, your sisters and cousins – and more than that, I am defending us all, as people.” Read more.

KRISTINA
In Slovakia, physical abuse, cutting women without consent, in cesarean and episiotomies is standard.  “Some hospitals women have no chance to leave the hospital without a cut.”  And the problem is this is all considered normal. Mothers know something isn’t right, they feel something is not right but they must just go on and focus on their baby.  Kristina had her first baby by c/sec. She wanted  a VBAC  and arrived to the hospital in active labor  at 8 cm, labor slowed  and she agreed to allow them to rupture  her membranes and give her synthetic oxytocin/pitocin, at 2:45 she felt the urge to push, with the mother tied down, Kristina said, “during the second stage two nurses jumped on chairs and pushed on my belly, that left bruises, was painful and I could not breathe, it felt like I would suffocate.”  (Kristeller Maneuver or Kristeller Pressure is strong pressure applied to the Uterus- see video).  Is it ok to receive an episiotomy that I did not consent to?

It is clear more and more women are suffering abuse, and post traumatic stress disorder and effect after childbirth and more and more women and men are speaking out and not only speaking but bringing cases to the courts to change the system and defend their human right to respect, dignity and decision making for themselves and their baby.  Some are also using Article 3 of European Convention on Human Rights (torture).  They are feeling that forced procedures in childbirth need stronger language than human rights.

Hermine concludes: “Why are we here to share them?  What is the value of sharing these stories? Consciousness raising has always been women talking, sharing their stories with each other.  There have been times and places where women’s talking has been considered a dangerous thing.  Any maybe it is, to some.  Because it is through sharing our stories that we understand how the very personal, private thing that happened to us fits into a bigger picture, one that invokes money, power and injustice.  It is through stories that the personal becomes political.  And so, if we want to see clarity around the basic autonomy rights of birthing women, their maternal rights to make decision on their babies’ behalf, and their reproductive right to pursue a physiological home birth, with a midwife, we can do nothing better than come together an talk about these legal proceedings, the people involved, and the legal arguments being made.”

To lift my spirits and to meet my long time hero Kerstin Uvnas-Moberg I attended the round table The Right to your own oxytocin!  Yes oxytocin and this lively informative new look at oxytocin both our own and synthetic lifting my spirit as did talking with Kerstin Uvnas-Moberg after about Orgasmic Birth! I will be sharing this discussion with you in an upcoming blog- easy sign up here to stay posted on future news and blogs.

Tweet

Pleasurable Breastfeeding Peer Support Resources

This year the theme of World Alliance for Breastfeeding Action WABA World Breastfeeding Week WBW is Peer Support!

Have you ever had a friend or family-member say, “I’m so glad you were there, you really helped me with breastfeeding.” ? This is peer support- WBW is all about highlighting that peer support and bringing it out into the community even more.

“Depending on the target group, the methods employed may include peer support groups at a community venue; drop-in sessions in a community or health facility for mothers with problems; home visits; phone, email, surface mail, mobile phone text or internet chat help; antenatal and parenting classes; or services linked to hospitals, health centres and community health services. Coordinating peer support with professional health care, between which mothers can be referred if necessary, is particularly valuable, because it builds a continuum of care from maternity hospital to the community”

Screen Shot 2013-07-31 at 11.16.21 AM
Hale eLearning for Peer Counselors

What kind of BF support do you have in your community?

There are many ways you can bring peer support to your community including hosting a support group or letting organizations know you are available to help. Here are some wonderful resources to get you started:

Linkages Training of Trainers for Mother-to-Mother Support Groups: http://www.linkagesproject.org/media/publications/Training%20Modules/MTMSG.pdf

Hale Publishing E-Learning “L-CERPs or R-CERPS are available for each eLearning class. Hale Publishing is a long-term provider with the International Board of Lactation Consultant Examiners for Continuing Education Recognition Points (CERPs). IBLCE Approval Number CLT108-25.”

World Health Organization Breastfeeding counseling: a training course: http://www.who.int/maternal_child_adolescent/documents/who_cdr_93_3/en/

WIC Screen Shot 2013-07-31 at 11.43.22 AMWorks Breastfeeding Training Resources (there are several resources listed within this one link): http://wicworks.nal.usda.gov/breastfeeding/breastfeeding-peer-counseling

There are many more resources on the World Breastfeeding Week website and we will be discussing peer support all week at: https://www.facebook.com/obirth so please join us!

 

Tweet

Protecting the Normal: Supporting Breastfeeding Mothers

Submitted by: Emily C. Taylor, MPC, IHI-IA, LCCE, CD(DONA)

Founder and Director of WISE (Women-Inspired Systems’ Enrichment)

Hendricks StS Skin to SkinAccording to the Oxford English Dictionary, normal means “Serving to establish a standard.  Of natural occurrence.  The usual, typical or expected state or condition.”  Rarely does this definition apply as precisely as it does to breastfeeding.  Let’s break that definition down: 1) it is, indeed, the standard by which all other methods of feeding a human infant are judged.  (Can’t you hear the formula ads proudly proclaiming, “Our closest even to breastmilk!”?)  2) Much like other natural occurrences, even the 93 chemical elements, breastfeeding is at its finest without artificial aid.  And, 3) the flow of milk from mother to child can safely be expected to transpire.

When then, if breastfeeding is so normal, do we insist on asking women “Do you plan to breastfeed?”  And, why, do so many women respond, “I’d like to try?”  As a doula, a childbirth educator, a Baby-Friendly Hospital expert, and as a woman, I’m sad to say it’s because well-intended “supporters” among us treat breastfeeding as if it is the exception.  Therefore, it is up to us to protect the normal until this paradigm shifts.  Here are three suggestions for mothers, birth workers, or anyone who wishes to don their super-heroes cape and protect the normal:

1)     Be smarter than the advertising.  Better yet, avoid it altogether… Denounce it!  In a recent study I published with my esteemed colleagues, we found that women’s confidence in their ability to breastfeed decreased remarkably after viewing a few common advertisements.  Before reviewing the ads, women decreed that mothers’ milk was best; after the ads, they wondered whether their own milk would meet their babies’ ever-changing needs.  I don’t care how beneficent these advertisements appear: They serve their purpose of getting women to use the products.

So, what can you do?  Ask your local hospitals and providers if they are compliant with the International Code of Marketing of Breastmilk Substitutes.  If so, they refrain from distributing formula company advertising.  If not, ask them to do so.   (Hospitals can register with www.banthebags.org to show their solidarity with the thousands of other hospitals who have signed on.  (Massachusetts and Rhode Island are bag-free states!)  If they won’t do it, tell everyone you know to leave those bags (or “educational materials” or coupons) behind.

2)     Go “Baby-Friendly”!  The Baby-Friendly Hospital Initiative is designed to give mothers and babies the optimal environment in which to start breastfeeding.  Staff is trained to provide evidence-based support on infant feeding, mothers are encouraged to hold their babies skin-to-skin, and to room-in continuously.  Only 6% of hospitals in the US are designated as Baby-Friendly.   But, you can make your own “Baby-Friendly” by requesting the practices for yourself and those you are serving.  Set the expectation: “The baby will be going skin-to-skin immediately after birth, and will stay there through at least the first feed.”  “The baby and mother will be rooming-in so they have an opportunity to practice baby-led feeding, and get to know each other with the support of the hospital staff.”  And, of course, stay close if you’re at home or a birth center, too!

3)     Learn about how the Affordable Care Act protects working mothers’ rights to breastfeed.  The ACA amends the Fair Labor Standards Act to require break time and a private place for hourly workers to nurse or express milk.  Employers sometimes need a bit of guidance about their role in protecting the normal.  Mothers and birth workers can (educate themselves and) point employers to the Division of Labor and the Office on Women’s Health.  A house bill called “Supporting Working Moms Act” is currently before the House of Representatives.  It seeks to expand ACA’s requirements to all employers.  Track S.934 so that you are ready to support it when its day arrives.

Above all, remind yourself that breastfeeding IS normal, and that like most things in this day and age, normal needs protecting.

Happy National Breastfeeding Month!

[Birth workers: If you would like to read more about protecting breastfeeding, check out our new book, Achieving Exclusive Breastfeeding: Translating Research into Action (Clinics in Human Lactation), by Labbok, Taylor or Parry, 2013.]

Also, see what the Surgeon General has to say on the matter by reading her Call to Action to Support Breastfeeding.

 

 headshot2Emily C. Taylor, MPC, IHI-IA, LCCE, CD(DONA), Achieving Exclusive Breastfeeding: Translating Research into Action (Clinics in Human Lactation), by Labbok, Taylor or Parry, 2013 is also Founder and Director of WISE (Women-Inspired Systems’ Enrichment).

 

For Debra’s Pleasurable weekly enews subscribe here.

Tweet

Eye-Doctor Finds New View on Breastfeeding

A Himba woman and her infant child in Namimbia.

Originally published February 13th, 2013
Yesterday I went for my annual eye exam. It seemed as routine as it sounds as I waited for my turn. As I sat in the chair it was hard to believe another year had passed. My eye doctor said to me “what do you do?”  He had vaguely remembered that I work in maternal child health globally. He shared with me that he was a Nestlé stockholder and recently was reading an article about  Nestlé selling infant formula and breast-feeding advocates concerns. He clearly thought that with free market there’s no reason why Nestlé should not be allowed to sell their formula and that women have the education and decision-making ability to decide if they want to breast-feed or if they want to purchase formula. I’m sure his response is very standard and seems reasonable to many.

I asked if he knew that thousands of babies die each year mostly in the developing countries when they use formula, that would not die if they were breastfed? Yes we agreed this is due to lack of access to clean water, lack of mixing properly, families diluting the formula to save money as well as the many short and long term health benefits that breastfeeding provides. He quickly said then why isn’t the focus on clean water? Why are governments held accountable to have clean water for everyone? While I agree on this I said to him what about governments responsibility to provide the best information and work toward optimal health for MotherBaby.  There is no company to gain from marketing breast-feeding. It is a public health issue! Every person, company and country should take a stand for the health of our youngest citizens. Finally the United States is getting involved.

Zanzibari woman breastfeeding

I offered the idea about how years ago cigarettes and alcohol were advertised on television. With good lobbying government finally banned Tobaco and alcohol companies from advertising realizing they must protect the information that goes to consumers that can influence their behaviors and have negative health consequences. I asked “can you see this same similarity here with formula?”.

He nodded gently.  I launched into the The Code (World Health Organization Publication WHO/MCH/NUT/90.1) says:

• NO advertising of breast-milk substitutes to the public.
• NO free samples to mothers.
• NO promotion of products in health-care facilities
• NO company “mothercraft” nurses to advise mothers.
• NO gifts or personal samples to health workers.
• NO words or pictures idealizing artificial feeding, including
pictures of infants on the products.
• Information to health workers should be scientific and factual.
• All information on artificial feeding, including the labels, should explain the benefits of breastfeeding, and the costs and
hazards associated with artificial feeding.
• Unsuitable products, such as condensed milk, should not be promoted for babies.
• All products should be of a high quality and take into account the climatic and storage conditions of the country where they are used.

To read more visit World Health Organization Publication WHO/MCH/NUT/90.1, visit Breastfeeding Online, and for many insights and resources about the code visit The International Baby Food Action Network.

While Nestle has limited in marketing in some low resource countries, why does it still violate the code in many middle to high resource countries? Don’t our babies deserve the best start? While I agree with his next statement that the U.S government and other government should regulate this as they do tobacco ads, I also feel that companies also have an ethical responsibility to uphold best practices. Nestle clearly has: been asked, seen boycotts of their products, and knows the ills that come from pushing formula. For details on this visit the Baby Milk Action site.

After a long discussion, my eye-doctor said, “you gave me a great deal to consider and look at from a new vantage point.” He finished my exam- my eyes are good and I left with a smile. You never know when you can educate and open a discussion to shift perception.

What are your thoughts on the WHO Code? What are your thoughts on Nestle?

Where have you opened up discussions about maternity care or breastfeeding?

Tweet

Become an obirth Affiliate

Pleasureable Birth Now it is easy to share the obirth videos and make money- just by sharing them on your website. This is a great opportunity to add content to your website while sharing the message of pleasure and possibilities in birth and life!

Choose one, two, three, or four of the obirth movies: Organic Birth, Pleasurable Birth 1, Pleasurable Birth 2, or Orgasmic Birth and simply click on the link for the video you want to embed.  Click “share”.  Where it reads “To begin earning money from sharing…”  fill in your email. You will be provided instantly with the embed code- right on the same screen.  Cut-n-paste the code into your source html code.  Do you see the video?  Congratulations!  It is that easy!

Now every time people pay to rent or purchase the video you will receive 10% of the purchase. This is great opportunity to add videos to your site, to make money doing it, and to share gentle birth.

Let us know if you want help setting it up.

Thanks for all the work you do to bring messages of gentle birth to the world.

We are happy to be a have our films digitally available thru Distrify.com.  Should you have technical difficulty downloading or viewing our digital films, please contact  Distrify Support center: http://support.distrify.com/customer/portal/emails/new

Tweet

Childbirth Climax

While in Malaysia this past week speaking about respectful care, I always love the opportunity to open up the topic of pleasure, ecstasy and Orgasmic Birth. It is too often a forgotten aspect of childbirth, or the one aspect that is avoided, as to talk about pleasure and/or the sexuality of birth can make many people uncomfortable. Yet, for me it is an essential topic if we are to look at the ways to honor, respect and offer women the options and care that will make childbirth as safe and easy as possible. To only talk about birth in our current medical, technocratic paradigm of pain and fear is to miss key elements that can transform childbirth and a woman’s experience of pain into pleasure, bliss and joy.

At the closing panel for Women Deliver, Kavita N Ramdas (Ford Foundation representative in New Delhi serving India, Nepal and Sri Lanka) gave a wonderful presentation summing up all the topics 4500 people from 159 countries had come together to discuss and brought up how we need to talk about pleasure too. I smiled, as I could not agree more. In addition this week Science Direct published Childbirth Climax: The Revealing of Obstetrical Orgasm stating, “Some mothers report experiencing intense physical pleasure during childbirth, which conflicts with popular belief and cultural taboos.” The author surveyed midwives; “the survey showed that 85% of the midwives questioned knew that it was possible to experience physical pleasure during childbirth. Nevertheless, 31% of respondents never observed a case, while 99% of the cases reported were observed by only 50% of the midwives questioned.”

Sitting in my hotel lobby in Kuala Lumpur, I was interviewed by Stephanie Pappas for my comments on the new study. I shared how many women have told me they never told anyone, including their partners, that birth was pleasurable as they felt ashamed that something our culture tells us should be only painful can be pleasurable. So, when asking caregivers how often they see pleasurable birth, I am not sure they always know what the women are feeling. Would you feel you need to share with your doctor or midwife if you had a pleasurable or orgasmic birth?

I am so grateful to the author of the study T. Postel, who adds another layer of information to open up our minds to all that birth can hold. In the conclusion: “by producing proof that a mother can experience physical pleasure during childbirth, this study constitutes an additional element in the understanding of the already- polymorphous female orgasmic response, and calls the function of orgasm back into question (Reich, 1986). It sheds new light on birthing conditions, midwife education, and labor preparation (Van Der Schueren, 2003).”

It is time we acknowledge scientifically the ability to find pleasure in childbirth. In addition, as T. Postel suggest we must look at the birth environment or as I call birth ambiance, we must include training on the natural physiology and the hormones of childbirth that can lead to pleasure in education for our midwives, nurses and physicians. As well as, we must provide education and offer preparation for women and men so that we recognize the connection between pain and pleasure and help women find the path to a safe, satisfying and pleasurable birth. As the article states, and I could not agree more, Orgasmic Birth should not be a performance standard, yet we should honor the potential for birth to be pleasurable and offer the options, environment and respectful care that optimizes the possibilities. I believe we must address why many people feel more comfortable with birth as painful and the mention of birth with pleasure as controversial.

Please share your thoughts and comments with me on this blog, the study, and the follow up article. To read Stephanie’s follow up article please visit: http://www.livescience.com/37039-orgasmic-birth-real.html.

I continue to collect women’s stories and comment and as I am preparing a webinar series, article and more on pleasurable birth, I hope to hear from you!

Pleasurably Yours,

Debra

Subscribe to Debra’s Weekly Pleasurable enews!

Tweet

The Noble Lie of Childbirth

Submitted by Guest Writer: Denny Hartung, MD

Plato Silanion Musei Capitolini © Marie-Lan Nguyen / Wikimedia Commons

Unless  you have a philosophy background, degree or interest, or are a fan of Plato, you may not have heard of the concept  of “The Noble Lie”.  I first heard about it in Washington, DC, at The International  Breech Conference in November, 2012. A wonderful midwife from Canada named Betty-Anne Daviss shared it while waxing philosophical at one of the lectures, and I share the concept humbly with you. I believe it has merit as we think about the childbirth experience over the spectrum of care today.

Betty-Anne told us The Noble Lie comes from Plato’s Republic.  It is a myth or “untruth”, if you will, told by an elite, to maintain or advance an agenda. I did a little more digging after the conference and found out, in the “Republic”, the myth went something like this:  Into whatever societal class you were born, there you will always remain and exist.  Slaves and serfs are always in the lowest class, landowners will always lord it over the serfs, and the politic or ruling class will always have most of the wealth and always rule.  If the ruling elite got the masses to believe that, then they maintained control and there was less chance that the masses would revolt and disrupt the status quo.  We know this idea today to be antithetical to the general good of society.  All have opportunity to improve their status in life, contribute to society to the fullest, and can grow, given the right circumstances.

The “Noble Lie” of childbirth, as Betty-Anne tells it, is this, “Women in childbirth need to be saved most of the time.” Her idea is that “the elite” are telling women they cannot give birth on their own. “You need that epidural.  Your baby needs continuous monitoring.  You need an IV.  You need pitocin to help you deliver your placenta.  You need that cesarean to save your baby from the difficulties of natural childbirth. You cannot deliver a breech baby vaginally.” I could go on and on.  One wonders if the childbirth industry is telling us that to maintain control too.  Something to think about…

Birth is a sentinel event in the human experience. The world is never the same after each and every birth.  A new life is here to change everything. Maybe another Mozart or Gandhi or Goethe has come.  Even more amazingly, a woman has been transformed into a mother.  The process and outcome should be given the respect it deserves.

I believe that women need “saving” from childbirth only rarely. Cesarean birth can be good – sometimes. Epidurals can be helpful – sometimes, as can pitocin, etc.  But, I believe we trivialize the experience of childbirth for each woman, her partner, her growing family, society and the global community when we disempower  her from the most powerful and difficult thing she will ever do.  Too much unnecessary intervention not only affects her, it affects our community adversely.  Once a woman has given birth, she knows what she is made of. Let’s not let the “Lie” lead us away from the real truth of childbirth.  Most of time she CAN DO IT.  As a mother, she can then help others through it.  She can lead our community and her family better.  She can withstand practically anything.  She is empowered.  She can change the world.

Debra, Gail Tully, & Dr. Dennis Hartung at 2013 Minneapolis Birth Symposium.
Debra, Gail Tully, & Dr. Dennis Hartung at 2013 Minneapolis Birth Symposium.

 

Denny Hartung, MD learned that art of gentle birthing while he served as an Army OB/GYN with military Nurse-Midwives for 11 years in Alaska.  Since his Army retirement in 2005,  he has practiced community Obstetrics and Gynecology in Hudson, WI, and in the eastern suburbs of the Twin Cities area of Minnesota.  He has an interest in VBAC/TOLAC and vaginal breech birth and promoting the midwifery model of care in obstetrics.

 

Subscribe to a Weekly blast of Pleasure in Debra’s Weekly Pleasurable enews

Tweet
  • « Go to Previous Page
  • Go to page 1
  • Go to page 2
  • Go to page 3
  • Go to page 4
  • Go to page 5
  • Go to page 6
  • Go to Next Page »

Footer

  •  7 Benefits of Taking Debra’s Doula Workshop
  • 10 Doula skills you will Learn at Debra’s DONA Doula Workshop
  • Would you like to join Debra’s Pain to Power With Pleasure and Passion Workshop? Learn more.
  • Attend a Conference where Debra is speaking.

Categories

RSS Debra Pascali-Bonaro Blog RSS

  • My Doula Story
  • Communal Grieving: A Reflection on 9/11 20 Years Later
  • Doula’s Role in creating Birth Equity
  • Graziella’s Kitchen
  • DONA Doula Certification

Sunken Treasure Publishing LLC © 2023 · Key birth photography by Sweet Births © 2014 · Privacy Policy · Terms of Use · Site Cookies