• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Debra Pascali-Bonaro

Awaken Your Inner Wisdom

  • ABOUT
    • ABOUT DEBRA
    • INVITE DEBRA TO SPEAK
    • START HERE
    • OUR TEAM
    • PRAISE
    • GIVE BACK
  • DOULA WORKSHOPS
    • DOULA SCHOLARSHIPS
  • DOULA RETREATS
  • EDUCATION FOR PARENTS
  • BLOG
    • BIRTH STORIES
      • Share your Story
  • PODCAST
  • CONTACT

deb

Attitude of Gratitude, Heart-full of Pleasure

paper-heart

Each morning I wake and say five things I am grateful for.  I have learned that an attitude of gratitude, not only begins each day with peace, but science is beginning to show us how we affect each cell and molecule in our body by the attitudes we hold.

Dr. Robert Emmons a professor of psychology at University of California Davis a foremost authority on the topic of Gratitude says: “Gratitude improves emotional and physical health, and it can strengthen relationships and communities.”  He published Thanks: How the New Science of Gratitude Can Make You Happier, an interdisciplinary book that provides a research-based synthesis of the topic as well as practical suggestions.

“Gratitude unlocks the fullness of life. It turns what we have into enough, and more. It can turn a meal into a feast, a house into a home, a stranger into a friend.” 
- Melody Beattie

This morning I woke early this morning before the sun rose to see a brilliant full moon lighting the early morning sky.  The glimmering light guided me as I gave thanks for many blessings and began my day with an attitude of gratitude.  In the last few years I have added my heart-full of pleasure.  This morning gave me many reasons to be grateful and to celebrate the pleasures of life.  In a few short minutes I can feel my body tingle and my heart fill with love as this simple practice transforms all that follows.

I packed the last items to bring with me as I begin my travels to join the circle of Austrian doulas and then onto Midwifery Today in Belgium.  In both places, I am looking forward to reconnecting with old friends who share a passion for optimal MotherBaby care as well as being excited to meet the many new birth workers who will join us as we share our vision for every woman’s right to give birth with dignity, respect, privacy, safety, support, pleasure and love and as we discuss Human Rights in Childbirth.

This week in preparation to open registration for Orgasmic Italy: a woman’s retreat to celebrate and deepen our appreciation of the pleasures of life, I have been enjoying photographs and savoring the many memories we shared in last year’s Pleasures of Italy retreat on the Amalfi Coast.  In the dim morning light I placed stamps on the notes we had written to each other to send three months later, which is today.  I can see us all on the beautiful terrace at Hotel Le Rocce with a spectacular view of the Amalfi coast below.  The Mediterranean Sea glistening as the morning sun reflects off it.  The smells of Italian coffee and fresh baked goodies.  The Italian pottery tables, with lemons and blues, against the backdrop of the mountain peaks of Agerola surrounding us in beauty and filling all our senses with bliss.  The connection we created with each other, and our own nurturing of ourselves has expanded my heart and fills me with love.  I can still see our drawings that captured our feelings as we wrote notes to send to ourselves and each other that I have kept on my desk these three months.  I am grateful yet again, reminded of the many pleasures we shared as well as our deep connection to nurture ourselves and each other as well as the commitment we made to continue enjoying the pleasures of life and celebrating each day.

The sun is gently rising now and I am off to begin another journey.  Join me in beginning your day with an attitude of gratitude and a heart-full of pleasure.  I hope to hear from you.  Please share your list of pleasures or maybe I will meet you at a workshop or retreat to celebrate the pleasures of life and birth in person.

Please share what are some things you are grateful for or what fills your heart with pleasure?

Tweet

Ina May is Officially a Great Woman

IMG_2030
Midwife Ina May Gaskin was inducted into the National Women’s Hall of Fame on October 2013 alongside with other “Great Women” including: Betty Ford, Julie Krone, Kate Millett, Nancy Pelosi, Bernice Resnick Sandler, Emma Hart Willard, Mother Mary Joseph Rogers, Anna Jacobson Schwartz.

Rarely is there a person who touches your life so deeply before you even meet her.

IMG_3242
Me and and Ina May outside PA capitol building May 11, 2012 for Safe Motherhood Quilt Rally to bring respect, dignity, quality, evidenced-based care to all.

Ina May’s Book Spiritual Midwifery not only contributed to give me the strength to stand up and deliver and birth as my intuition told me, her book started me on my path to enjoy and pass along pleasure in childbirth.

Years later when we finally met, I was touched yet again by her words of wisdom and her gracious, wise, fun presence.  Her words of  Orgasmic Birth… well you know where they took me!  I feel so blessed to know Ina May and have shared many talks and travels together. Whether you have met her, heard her speak, or read her book, I hope you join me in celebrating the amazing woman/midwife she is and honor her years of work, wisdom and blessings that she has shared with so many!  Being Inducted into the National Women’s Hall of Fame: Showcasing Great Women is so well deserved!  Ina May Gaskin is shining a spotlight for us to follow on the path to Optimal MotherBaby Care and Midwifery!

We are excited to bring you this video clip of Ina May’s Acceptance Speech from the National Women’s Hall of Fame 24th Induction Ceremony, as lovingly recorded by Robbie E. Davis-Floyd, Ph.D.

So let’s look at other ways Ina May’s “Greatness” has been illustrated….

Quotes! Your body is not a lemon! Let your monkey brain do it! The Energy that Get’s The Baby In Get’s the Baby Out!!

You may all be familiar with this famous Ina May quote:

Remember this, for it is as true as true gets: Your body is not a lemon. You are not a machine. The Creator is not a careless mechanic. Human female bodies have the same potential to give birth well as aardvarks, lions, rhinoceri, elephants, moose and water buffalo. Even if it has not been your habit throughout your life so far, I recommend that you learn to think positively about your body. Ina May Gaskin

This video is one of Ina May’s favorites and well-illustrates the “Your Body is not a lemon” quote.

To hear more great quotes from Ina May, listen to “The Modern Midwife: Ina May Gaskin” Interview aired in September by American Public Media The Story.

Interview for American Public Media's The Story
Interview for American Public Media’s The Stor

“In 1971, Ina May Gaskin founded “The Farm,” a place where women can give birth without machines or drugs.  She tells guest host Phoebe Judge about giving birth to her own children conventionally, an experience so rough it moved her to find another way. When she first began her work as a midwife, she says, she knew little more than that you should be nice to the mother. “That’s what I did,” she says. In the decades since, Gaskin’s approach to natural childbirth has appealed to thousands of women.” Listen to the interview at http://www.thestory.org/stories/2013-09/modern-midwife-ina-may-gaskin.

In 2012 we were treated to “Birth Story: Ina May Gaskin & the Farm Midwives” Documentary and led thru many of the wonderful experiences and achievements in Ina May’s life including: The Farm in Tennessee; her skill and knowledge about delivering a breech birth; how she was introduced to the Gaskin Maneuver used to relieve Shoulder Dystocia; her theory on the Sphincter Law, & the Safe Motherhood Quilt Project.

And recently Ina May presented at TEDxSacramento about Reducing Fear of Birth in U.S. Culture.

Debra & Ina May
As I was walking onto the stage to speak at the Woman and Nature Conference (Wroclaw, Poland, October, 2013), I heard a whole lot of cheering from the audience. I knew there were doulas there. Later, Ina May Gaskin said to me, “you can always hear the doulas, the wildness in their voices and their passion they bring to childbirth.”

 

 

Thank you Ina May for shining a spotlight for us to follow on the path to Optimal MotherBaby Care and Midwifery!

How has Ina May shone the spotlight for you?

Tweet

Eye-Doctor Finds New View on Breastfeeding

A Himba woman and her infant child in Namimbia.

Originally published February 13th, 2013
Yesterday I went for my annual eye exam. It seemed as routine as it sounds as I waited for my turn. As I sat in the chair it was hard to believe another year had passed. My eye doctor said to me “what do you do?”  He had vaguely remembered that I work in maternal child health globally. He shared with me that he was a Nestlé stockholder and recently was reading an article about  Nestlé selling infant formula and breast-feeding advocates concerns. He clearly thought that with free market there’s no reason why Nestlé should not be allowed to sell their formula and that women have the education and decision-making ability to decide if they want to breast-feed or if they want to purchase formula. I’m sure his response is very standard and seems reasonable to many.

I asked if he knew that thousands of babies die each year mostly in the developing countries when they use formula, that would not die if they were breastfed? Yes we agreed this is due to lack of access to clean water, lack of mixing properly, families diluting the formula to save money as well as the many short and long term health benefits that breastfeeding provides. He quickly said then why isn’t the focus on clean water? Why are governments held accountable to have clean water for everyone? While I agree on this I said to him what about governments responsibility to provide the best information and work toward optimal health for MotherBaby.  There is no company to gain from marketing breast-feeding. It is a public health issue! Every person, company and country should take a stand for the health of our youngest citizens. Finally the United States is getting involved.

Zanzibari woman breastfeeding

I offered the idea about how years ago cigarettes and alcohol were advertised on television. With good lobbying government finally banned Tobaco and alcohol companies from advertising realizing they must protect the information that goes to consumers that can influence their behaviors and have negative health consequences. I asked “can you see this same similarity here with formula?”.

He nodded gently.  I launched into the The Code (World Health Organization Publication WHO/MCH/NUT/90.1) says:

• NO advertising of breast-milk substitutes to the public.
• NO free samples to mothers.
• NO promotion of products in health-care facilities
• NO company “mothercraft” nurses to advise mothers.
• NO gifts or personal samples to health workers.
• NO words or pictures idealizing artificial feeding, including
pictures of infants on the products.
• Information to health workers should be scientific and factual.
• All information on artificial feeding, including the labels, should explain the benefits of breastfeeding, and the costs and
hazards associated with artificial feeding.
• Unsuitable products, such as condensed milk, should not be promoted for babies.
• All products should be of a high quality and take into account the climatic and storage conditions of the country where they are used.

To read more visit World Health Organization Publication WHO/MCH/NUT/90.1, visit Breastfeeding Online, and for many insights and resources about the code visit The International Baby Food Action Network.

While Nestle has limited in marketing in some low resource countries, why does it still violate the code in many middle to high resource countries? Don’t our babies deserve the best start? While I agree with his next statement that the U.S government and other government should regulate this as they do tobacco ads, I also feel that companies also have an ethical responsibility to uphold best practices. Nestle clearly has: been asked, seen boycotts of their products, and knows the ills that come from pushing formula. For details on this visit the Baby Milk Action site.

After a long discussion, my eye-doctor said, “you gave me a great deal to consider and look at from a new vantage point.” He finished my exam- my eyes are good and I left with a smile. You never know when you can educate and open a discussion to shift perception.

What are your thoughts on the WHO Code? What are your thoughts on Nestle?

Where have you opened up discussions about maternity care or breastfeeding?

Tweet

Le Plaisir d’Accoucher: Pleasure of Birthing

Here is Mr. Bernard Bel’s of AFAR response to Debra’s backstory about the Orgasmic verse Organic Birth titles….

Screen Shot 2013-07-17 at 12.34.38 PMDear Debra,

Long ago (in 2001) a group of birth activists led by two homebirth midwives invited us for a contribution to the public show they organise every year in the context of International Women’s Day. Since I was collecting interviews of women who had unassisted births, I suggested that we invite a few of them to speak about their experience. The title of their intervention would be “Le plaisir d’accoucher, pourquoi s’en priver?” which means: “Pleasure of birthing, why should we avoid it?”  The organizers felt shocked with the title and this contribution was canceled on the pretext that it would generate “bad reactions from the press”… Their main problem was to promote the case of intelligent women who did not rely on the care of midwives for a secure birthing. However they felt equally disturbed by the notion of pleasure associated with childbirth. One of them confessed that after thirty years of practice as a homebirth midwife she had never noticed anything pleasurable in the experience of her patients!

In those days writings such as “Resexualizing childbirth” (Leilah McCracken) and a few pleasurable birth stories started circulating but only in a very small circle of people who could read English and communicate via internet. We started publishing birth stories, encouraging parents (and caregivers) to share their experience in writing. Gradually the idea that birth may “also” be pleasurable made its way, at least women experiencing it were no longer seen as hysterical nymphomaniacs. 😉 I often argued that sex can be the most pleasurable experience in life wheras it becomes a horrible and painful event when forced or even disturbed by someone’s will.

Indeed, pleasure in birthing requires more than the respect of privacy, but privacy and gentle care are necessary conditions for it to happen.

For these reasons I personally would keep a title like “Orgasmic birth” for the original film and a slightly less provocative one such as “Le plaisir d’accoucher” (Pleasure of Birthing) for the shorter version. Both of them would convey the idea of pleasure and we would avoid discusions about what is “natural” triggered by the word “organic”.

I let you know about more comments.

All the best,

Bernard

To read Debra’s original response to Mr. Bel’s inquiry about the titles please click here.

To receive a weekly dose of Pleasure in your inbox subscribe here.

 

Tweet

Creating a Name: Organic and Orgasmic Birth

Debra was asked about the different film titles: Organic and Organic from Mr. Bernard Bel of AFAR: Alliance francophone pour l’accouchement respecté. Mr. Bel explained that people were concerned (or horrified to be exact) that the Organic title was an attempt at self-censorship of the Orgasmic Birth title and further explained that in France ” ‘organic’ food/farming is still perceived as a marginal activity and “natural” is often associated with a regressive vision of women being naturally “complimentary to men” – as recently spelled out by a proposal for the Tunisian constitution (inspired by religious fundamentalists). Whereas “orgasmic” is undoubtedly connected with pleasure and freedom, i.e. democratic values.” It is so interesting how the same word can have such a different context in different languages and cultures! This discussion inspired Debra to write the backstory about the titles. Here it is….

Screen Shot 2013-07-17 at 11.38.00 AM

I know many of you are wondering why the name changes from Orgasmic to Organic Birth. I’ll begin with why we even chose the title “Orgasmic Birth: The Best-Kept Secret” in the first place. Some of you that have attended screenings with me over the years have heard this story of how I attended a pitch session in New York City for independent filmmakers. We were in the middle of making Orgasmic Birth and our working title was An Ordinary Miracle: Global Models of Care. The film was the same vision as it today, about pleasurable birth but we didn’t yet have a title that reflected the power and possibility that birth offers in our lives.

The day of the pitch session I was teaching a workshop in New York City.  I had spent a great deal of time talking about the sexuality of birth, the ecstatic hormones of labor and “Orgasmic Birth”.  One of the women who was at the workshop was also a filmmaker.  When I mentioned I had to leave right on time to attend an independent film pitch session with top Television executives, she offered to come with me and be my film doula.  We were all gathered in a big auditorium with a long table down below with executives from different networks.  I felt like it was the American Idol of filmmakers.  I waited and waited and finally my name was called out.  I was asked to stand right where I was and begin my pitch.  I stated my name is Debra Pascali-Bonaro and my film in production is An Ordinary Miracle: Global Models of Care.  One of the gentlemen said you can sit down now.  I quickly stated I thought I had 10 min. to share about my film.  He said with a title like that he didn’t need to know anymore as I wouldn’t have an audience for this film.  I quickly, shared my 2nd working title, which was  Ecstatic Birth.  He repeated please sit down.  My film doula next me hit me as I was coming down to my seat and said: “yell out “Orgasmic Birth”.  Under my breath, I said “I can’t”.   She said: “Why! What do you have to lose?”.  So with that I jumped back up and yelled out “Orgasmic Birth!”  The auditorium broke into laughter and the gentleman in the front said:  “Now, that is not possible?” I went into my 10 min. about the sensuality, sexuality and the possibility for pleasure, bliss, ecstasy and orgasmic joy in labor birth and beyond.  “We birth the way we live”.  He ended my 10 minutes by saying if you make that film you will have something people will be intrigued by.  I sat down smiling and then thought am I really going to step out to the world with the title Orgasmic Birth?

Running through my mind was something my friends had said: the definition of insanity is to… do the same thing and expect different results.  I knew it was time to borrow a slogan from Karen Brody “To be bold!”  I was ready to step out and speak about the ecstatic bliss and joy available to women and men during childbirth.  We needed to have a new discussion if we were to make change in birth around the world.

Well as they say, the rest is history.  We released Orgasmic Birth in the end of 2008. Orgasmic Birth has traveled to 46 countries, numerous film festivals and is translated into 10 languages.  We continue to receive interviews weekly from around the world.  So you ask, why did we create a shorter 52 min. version with a new opening, a new birth and revised editing of many of the scenes?  We have been asked to create a broadcast version to air in many countries around the world.  A broadcast hour is  52 minutes of film.  I welcomed the opportunity to go back into the edit room after having watched the film literally thousands of times and redo some of the scenes with a new eye.  After many hours of work, money and time put into the new addition, we thought what else could we do with it to share it with the world?

It was decided we would release our new, revised, shorter version of Orgasmic Birth  as a DVD.  If we use the same title how would people know the difference between the two?  Should it be  Orgasmic Birth 2?  That did not feel right to us. We knew we needed a new name, a way that people could distinguish between the two copies.  Over the 3 years since the release of Orgasmic Birth we’ve notice consistently that 40% of our Google analytics come from people googling the name Organic Birth.  I had often wondered; did people really think we were saying the word organic not orgasmic?  Maybe with our focus on organic gardening and organic living it seems more culturally appropriate.  So another late night searching for a title, we thought let’s give people what they’re looking for Organic Birth.

Orgasmic Birth’s cover is the color red so we made Organic Birth green.  We call Orgasmic Birth: The Best-Kept Secret,  Organic Birth’s tag line is Birth is Natural! Organic Birth is still about pleasure, ecstasy, transformation, facing our fears, and finding orgasmic pleasure.  It is a slightly gentler approaching, sharing all that is possible in birth.  Our new version is another approach to bring a message to the wider world.

Orgasmic Birth still creates a larger discussion, sells more and generates the controversy needed to look into the issues and make change.  We must view the connection between birth and a woman’s sexuality.  For if we are to truly support women and their partners, fathers and others in childbirth, we must see the sacred, sensual connection to how our hormones and physiology of birth and sex are connected.

If caregivers honored the intimacy of birth: created privacy, ensured all women felt safe, offered a variety of comfort measures, many more women would find their way to an easier, safer and more blissful, orgasmic experience.

In the end, I believe each film Orgasmic Birth: The Best-Kept Secret and Organic Birth: Birth is Natural!  add to the discussion and can be used in different ways and settings to help woman and men see all that is possible in birth and beyond.

I welcome your thoughts and feedback.  Have you seen both versions? Which one do you like better? How do you feel about our titles? What is your favorite quote? Both version of our film are now available on the Orgasmic Birth website for digital rental or purchase a well as to purchase DVD’s. 

Read Mr. Bernard Bel’s response here.

Subscribe to Debra’s enews and receive Pleasure weekly in your inbox!

Tweet

Pleasures of Life with Love, in Agerola

DETAILS AVAILABLE SOON for ORGASMIC ITALY 2014- Sign up here.

1072399_400857836702057_260659349_oI am sitting by the pool for my last morning in Agerola as I savor the memories, the magic, the beauty, the people and the views atop the Amalfi coast in Agerola, nicknamed Little Switzerland. High above the Mediterranean Sea, the views take your breath away.  From our Hotel Le Rocce we see both the mountains of Agerola and the Mediterranean Sea below glistening and reflecting the July sun shimmering and dancing on the water where the sea and the sky blend, taking us into infinity with our views and our dreams.  It is Orgasmic Italy!  My new name for our new weeklong retreat and tour with my cousin Graziella.  We are taken back in time living in a traditional Italian Village where we share our lives, finding pleasure in the food, people, views.  Our lives open up and expand in ways that words cannot fully capture.  Love, happiness and music flow freely.

Guiding our woman’s circle for 7 blissful days, I am blessed.  Opening to new elements in our lives, we created friendships and memories to last a lifetime.  Taking the beauty we discovered within and around us home, we will integrate those discoveries into our lives.  Because words can capture some of the magic, here are quotes from participants to inspire you to find pleasure today where ever you are:

“I enjoyed the most pleasurable week of multi orgasmic experiences ;). Love, share, care, learn, adventure in a truly magical & mystical environment! Together in the company of very beautiful wonderful woman I enjoyed delicious Italian food, warm Italian hospitality, stunning nature. Most special for me was our boat trip along the Amalfi coast with Panini & Prosecco bubbles and refreshing swims. My heart softens & opens up of the fairytale memory of our enchanting trip between worlds in the Valley of the Fairy’s. A part of me still lingers there & a part of the valley lives as part of me now.” ~Ursula

“Breathing in the fragrances and pure air high above the Amalfi coast, I look out on the Mediterranean sea from my room.  Ageroleans open their arms and hearts in welcome. From the “biologique” food served in several hundred-year-old palazzos to mountain walks in the Valley of the Fairies, my stay has been a feast of the senses.  There is magic here.” ~ Roberta

Where do you do to find Orgasmic Bliss in your life?

Would you like to join us for our Orgasmic Italy taking place June 15 – 22, 2014?  Join our mailing list for more information as it become available in the coming weeks, and sign up early for our early bird discount!

 

Tweet

Hormone of Pleasure Released at Bassano Workshop

Sarah Buckley MD and Midwife Verena Schmidt join the Bassano Workshop.
Sarah Buckley MD and Midwife Verena Schmidt join the Bassano Workshop.

Warm sunny days and cool breezy nights have added to a transcendent week in Bassano de Grappa Italy with 13 doulas gathered in Chiara’s beautiful Villa in the mountains overlooking the village.

Sarah Buckley, MD joined me for the Introduction to Childbirth for the DONA birth doula workshop. Sarah’s must read book Gentle Birth; Gentle Mothering is part of my recommended reading for all expectant women and birth workers.

It is such an honor to hear Sarah speak once again, about the conditions that are needed for MotherBaby hormones to flow optimally. “A woman or any mammals needs to feel safe, private and unobserved.” With the ideal conditions a laboring women finds her zone, as Ina May Gaskin says, “If a woman in labor is not looking like a goddess she is not being treated right!” When the woman is releasing elevated levels of oxytocin the love hormone, also called the hormone of calm, connection she is also receiving a great pain reliever. In addition, beta-endorphin, the hormone of pleasure, takes a woman to an altered state.

Sarah continues: “The Native Americans say the laboring woman goes out to the stars to bring back the soul of the baby. Babies also produce beta-endorphin creating a pleasurable mutual dependency. Every mammalian mother needs these rewards to fall in love and care for her baby.” “But, if the Saber tooth Tiger shows up we have high levels of adrenaline, which can slow or stop labor. In a hospital birth the tiger can be strangers, those the mother does not know or feel safe with, a doula can help her to feel safe.”

It is essential that we understand the physiology of birth so that you can create the birth ambiance and choose the people and the setting that will allow your hormones to flow optimally, not only creating a safer, easier birth, but also able to move from pain to pleasure. Sarah’s presentation is a gift for the doulas, and to me, as I always love to hear the gentle ways she presents this important essential knowledge.

Bassano Dining
Speaking of pleasure, the Italians bring pleasure to every sense, as our lunches are prepared with love, from organic produce, each dish is visually beautiful, the tastes are beyond words, served on the rooftop. I am filled with bliss, my every sense is stimulated and I am filled with an “orgasmic” high.

This Italian doula workshop is truly the “orgasmic” doula workshop, filling us with love, wisdom, tastes, song, dance and more!!

After one of our ecstatic meals together, Elena Skoko, author of Memoirs of a Singing Birth, and husband, Roberto and daughter Coco, sing to us as mothers nurse their babies and toddlers and doulas smile and sway as our collective oxytocin and emotions flow. A beautiful end to another blissful doula workshop-day, where we discussed rebozos and the doulas role in providing comfort in childbirth.

Daniela, a doula and lactation consultant offered us her passion and wisdom in a three hour Breastfeeding class that meets yet another requirement for DONA certification.

Verena Schmid, an amazing, wise Italian midwife, joined the circle too and shared about postpartum care and the golden first hour after birth. At night, Verena joined me for the first screening or Orgasmic Birth: The Best-Kept Secret in a theater in Bassano.

This is truly a special workshop where a DONA International doula trainer, a physician, midwife, lactation consultant, singers, amazing cooks, incredible doulas, have joined together in a circle to broaden our knowledge about the physiology of childbirth, understand the doulas role in supporting mother’s partners and babies, learn comfort measures, share our experiences, heal, grow and learn to support challenging births, while creating a lasting memory full of emotions, friendship and oxytocin. This has been a unique and incredible experience for us all. Together we have created an additional link in the bridge between midwives, physicians and doulas in Italy.

We have our closing dinner yet to come, look for our photos on facebook.com/obirth as we celebrate an end to a life changing week near the famous Bridge in Bassano de Grappa.

Tweet

The Noble Lie of Childbirth

Submitted by Guest Writer: Denny Hartung, MD

Plato Silanion Musei Capitolini © Marie-Lan Nguyen / Wikimedia Commons

Unless  you have a philosophy background, degree or interest, or are a fan of Plato, you may not have heard of the concept  of “The Noble Lie”.  I first heard about it in Washington, DC, at The International  Breech Conference in November, 2012. A wonderful midwife from Canada named Betty-Anne Daviss shared it while waxing philosophical at one of the lectures, and I share the concept humbly with you. I believe it has merit as we think about the childbirth experience over the spectrum of care today.

Betty-Anne told us The Noble Lie comes from Plato’s Republic.  It is a myth or “untruth”, if you will, told by an elite, to maintain or advance an agenda. I did a little more digging after the conference and found out, in the “Republic”, the myth went something like this:  Into whatever societal class you were born, there you will always remain and exist.  Slaves and serfs are always in the lowest class, landowners will always lord it over the serfs, and the politic or ruling class will always have most of the wealth and always rule.  If the ruling elite got the masses to believe that, then they maintained control and there was less chance that the masses would revolt and disrupt the status quo.  We know this idea today to be antithetical to the general good of society.  All have opportunity to improve their status in life, contribute to society to the fullest, and can grow, given the right circumstances.

The “Noble Lie” of childbirth, as Betty-Anne tells it, is this, “Women in childbirth need to be saved most of the time.” Her idea is that “the elite” are telling women they cannot give birth on their own. “You need that epidural.  Your baby needs continuous monitoring.  You need an IV.  You need pitocin to help you deliver your placenta.  You need that cesarean to save your baby from the difficulties of natural childbirth. You cannot deliver a breech baby vaginally.” I could go on and on.  One wonders if the childbirth industry is telling us that to maintain control too.  Something to think about…

Birth is a sentinel event in the human experience. The world is never the same after each and every birth.  A new life is here to change everything. Maybe another Mozart or Gandhi or Goethe has come.  Even more amazingly, a woman has been transformed into a mother.  The process and outcome should be given the respect it deserves.

I believe that women need “saving” from childbirth only rarely. Cesarean birth can be good – sometimes. Epidurals can be helpful – sometimes, as can pitocin, etc.  But, I believe we trivialize the experience of childbirth for each woman, her partner, her growing family, society and the global community when we disempower  her from the most powerful and difficult thing she will ever do.  Too much unnecessary intervention not only affects her, it affects our community adversely.  Once a woman has given birth, she knows what she is made of. Let’s not let the “Lie” lead us away from the real truth of childbirth.  Most of time she CAN DO IT.  As a mother, she can then help others through it.  She can lead our community and her family better.  She can withstand practically anything.  She is empowered.  She can change the world.

Debra, Gail Tully, & Dr. Dennis Hartung at 2013 Minneapolis Birth Symposium.
Debra, Gail Tully, & Dr. Dennis Hartung at 2013 Minneapolis Birth Symposium.

 

Denny Hartung, MD learned that art of gentle birthing while he served as an Army OB/GYN with military Nurse-Midwives for 11 years in Alaska.  Since his Army retirement in 2005,  he has practiced community Obstetrics and Gynecology in Hudson, WI, and in the eastern suburbs of the Twin Cities area of Minnesota.  He has an interest in VBAC/TOLAC and vaginal breech birth and promoting the midwifery model of care in obstetrics.

 

Subscribe to a Weekly blast of Pleasure in Debra’s Weekly Pleasurable enews

Tweet
  • « Go to Previous Page
  • Page 1
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 4
  • Page 5
  • Page 6
  • Page 7
  • Page 8
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 10
  • Go to Next Page »

Footer

  •  7 Benefits of Taking Debra’s Doula Workshop
  • 10 Doula skills you will Learn at Debra’s DONA Doula Workshop
  • Would you like to join Debra’s Pain to Power With Pleasure and Passion Workshop? Learn more.
  • Attend a Conference where Debra is speaking.

Categories

RSS Debra Pascali-Bonaro Blog RSS

  • My Doula Story
  • Communal Grieving: A Reflection on 9/11 20 Years Later
  • Doula’s Role in creating Birth Equity
  • Graziella’s Kitchen
  • DONA Doula Certification

Sunken Treasure Publishing LLC © 2025 · Key birth photography by Sweet Births © 2014 · Privacy Policy · Terms of Use · Site Cookies